oaks
don't think this is the strongest renewal of a classic that is never that strong but this is as wide open an oaks as i can remember. the race revolves around whether desert flower stays 1m4f in rain softened ground or whether she will prove as effective away from newmarket and i'm not entirely convinced of either. to give her credit, she has always done her best work when meeting the rising ground over 1m but she has always been well positioned at a track that rewards well positioned horses. she's a nicely balanced horse and coming out of stall one she is likely to get a desired prominent position once again so while there are questions she has the tools and draw that give her the best hope to provide answers. there are enough doubts for me to look elsewhere although those doubts are quite clearly built in to her price. 2.6x isn't a bad number and i wouldn't be laying her but there is some very solid each way value with elite upside given the relatively short priced favourite's range of outcomes.
aidan o'brien has a deep hand although i don't believe it to be all that strong. personally i think ryan moore has chosen the third best horse (of three) in minnie hauk. she's fairly inexperienced but chester can teach a young horse a lot and she won well enough. that form, however, is extremely weak and she didn't look entirely at home on the idiosyncratic track round the bend before coming back on the bridle at the top of the straight. she's obviously at least a somewhat talented work in progress that is going to keep on improving but second fav in an oaks when she is nowhere near the finished product is a stretch. she's a big old cunt and given how she handled the turn at chester i have some concerns about her ability to handle the track.
giselle a very similar type of horse, big fucker racing on a tight track but she looked more at home around lingfield than minnie did at chester so it was a good prep run. a three runner field with two absolute no hopers not ideal but she quickened up very smartly against the rail and won as she liked. a strong headed individual she will need to do a much better job at settling if she's to win this and it's a concern that the first time hood didn't do much of a job settling her down but it was a small field with little pace and there should be a better gallop to aim at here. the market has been very positive on her throughout her career so i would be certain the stable believe there is a lot more to come from her and she has taken some money overnight. she's a lively each way contender with real win upside but if i were betting her i would likely bet her win only at ~9/1 because i am worried that she will get too worked up and be too keen early. have taken some win tricast combos in my desire to take on desert flower and minnie hauk and she is in those.
the market strongly disagrees but i had whirl as the best bet of the o'brien horses and i've chased this price all the way up because my ego is so big and dumb that i think i just know better when clearly i don't so it will cost my a few coins when she is out the back of the tv but there's no need to be a pussy in a big race. she doesn't have the upside of her stable mates but she is an experienced racehorse that improved a significant amount for stepping up to 1m2f last time and she once again did all of her best work at the finish. it wasn't the strongest race and i won't pretend there aren't doubts about her ability at this level but i think her level now is very competitive in a race full of promising improvers that haven't proven much to date and i have zero question marks about the race make up either. she has, in my opinion, significantly the most solid profile for this race and a wonderful battling attitude to go with it. would not be at all surprised if there was a horse or two that improved beyond her but there is an incredible amount of value in the place part of an ew bet imo.
revoir would be a surprise winner. she had every chance to go by on seasonal reappearance and just wasn't good enough. potentially inconvenienced by slow pace but she was relatively well positioned herself. went off 10/1 in a listed race that day and is now 10/1 in a deep enough g1. should improve, ground won't be an issue but that price is certainly tight enough to consider.
elwateen flattered by her run in the guineas but it was a seasonal debut in a strong race having only ever seen the racetrack once before so she can be expected to improve with the step up in trip likely to suit. one of the more unknown types. i don't have much opinion about her other than i think she has to find quite a lot. could though.
taken some each way bets on wemightakedlongway at 16/1 and she's also going in the tricast combos. she got a soft enough lead when winning a fairly weak race full of inexperienced horses the last day but the second looks like a real nice type and she ran away from her the further they went and she should really benefit from this type of test up in trip. she's not ideally drawn for a horse that likely wants to be prominent but there isn't a confirmed front runner in here at this trip and she is one of the more likely to press forward so she has a live chance to go and dictate this raceif she can get across early from a not inconceivable post. the return run against the boys was a very solid run and i think she has plenty of ability.